Kyle, I'm puzzled by your LJ expirement.
If I'm reading between your lines correctly, I get the feeling that you're hypothesizing that driving the chest doesn't improve your LJ performance ... so therefore it doesn't improve your PV performance ... so therefore you shouldn't do it. Is that it?
If so, then I think you're going down the wrong path of experimentation.
As Agapit says, chest drive helps pole penetration at the expense of delaying the "pull-push" that he advocates in his PV manifesto. Also remember that he's proposing a technique that will allow someone to clear 6.40. To date, no one to my knowledge ... including Bubka ... has been able to execute Agapit's 6.40 model as advocated. The fact that Agapit CLAIMS that Bubka has had some 6.40 clearances over some imaginary bars does NOT mean that he's executed the 6.40 model successfully. It only means that the model that Bubka helped Petrov develop ... the PETROV MODEL ... and used for his entire elite career ... not the 6.40 MODEL ... is capable of being used to clear 6.40.
Be careful not to assume that anyone other than maybe Bubka and Isaksson might be able to execute the 6.40 model. And since they're both retired now, it ain't gonna happen anytime soon. BTW, if Bubka was AWARE of the 6.40 Model ... then why didn't he try to use it ... and why didn't he clear 6.40 with it? (I know, I know, he went up a cm at a time ... and ran out of time.)
It's awfully difficult for every other "mere mortal" pole vaulter to do a handstand on the highbar from a hanging start ... and so it's equally difficult for us to properly execute the 6.40 model as Agapit has envisioned. I know I can't do that highbar trick ... can you ... or can you name anyone that can? Could Bubka? If anyone could, I'm conjecturing that it might have been Isaksson.
KYLE ELLIS wrote: Should we use the term chest drive, or is this an illusion in the vault resulting from finishing the takeoff foot and planting with elastic shoulders?
You can call it what you like, but chest drive is the result of "planting with elastic shoulders" and "finishing the takeoff" to the point where you have your entire body stretched in a C like an elastic band ... ready to whip back into a vigorous downswing.
THAT'S the advantage of the chest drive.
It's strange that you say "planting with elastic shoulders" tho. In reality, the plant comes first ... then THE TAKEOFF ... then the finishing of the takeoff ... and then the stretching of the shoulders in unison with the stretching of the trail leg. Did you forget the TAKEOFF? OK, there's lots of overlap on these vault parts, so let's not quibble too much about the precise timing of them. It's just that I would expect the plant to be finished well before the shoulders start becoming "elastic".
It really has nothing to do with how well you jump off the ground a la your LJ expirement. The two are quite unrelated, IMHO.
I see that you were able to jump an extra 29" by focussing on "trying to accelerate off the board" rather than "driving the chest".
I'm puzzled as to why you wouldn't strive to do both ... first one, then the other ... first ACCELERATE OFF THE BOARD ... and then ... ONCE YOU'RE OFF THE BOARD ... drive the chest thru as you PRESS and SQUEEZE with your top hand, as the pole hits the box ...
... oh ... I forgot

... you're not carrying a pole ... so you have nothing to PRESS and SQUEEZE against ... and the pole that you're not carrying isn't going to hit the box that's not there ... so this chest driving expirement in LJ isn't going to work ... is it?
You see the problem?
I suggest that the chest drive comes AFTER your takeoff (AFTER you leave the ground) ... so it should have no effect whatsoever on your LJ experiment ... if done properly!
My conclusion on why you're able to add 29" to your LJ is that you're letting your focus of the CHEST DRIVE interfere with your focus on the ACCELERATION OFF THE BOARD.
If you SUCCESSFULLY focus on one and then the other ... without letting the CHEST DRIVE interfere with the ACCELERATION OFF THE BOARD, then there should be no difference whatsoever between your LJ attempts each way!
I know it requires some focus and practice ... but I'm quite sure that you can do it once you practice it 10,000+ times!

I know I did!

Kirk